Source: eBird Observation Dataset (Cornell Lab of Ornithology) via GBIF, records 2015–2025, CC BY 4.0; summarized into typical dates, not a forecast. Data updated Nov 16, 2026; refreshed once a year when GBIF publishes a new eBird release. Methodology · Report an error
Through the year
How common Pine Siskins are among all bird sightings in New York, day by day, 2015–2025.
What to expect
Pine Siskins usually reach New York around October 11, the day the first 10% of fall sightings are in. In most years from 2015 to 2025 that date fell between Oct 8 and Oct 18, based on 19,768 fall records.
- Timing varies inside the state: across 20 counties with enough sightings, Monroe County is earliest (Oct 6) and Saratoga County latest (Oct 16), 10 days apart.
- In 2025 they arrived on Oct 9, 4 days earlier than the ten years before.
- Allowing for how many people were out birding, the date moves 6 days later, to Oct 17: a few early birds show up first, and the main wave follows.
- New York is one of the early states, 8th of 32. The biggest gap with a neighbor is Connecticut, 8 days later.
- 2016 was the earliest year (Oct 1) and 2018 the latest (Oct 21).
- Checked against 2025, the typical date from 2015-2024 missed the actual 2025 date by 4 days. Across 28 states the typical miss for Pine Siskins was 4 days, so New York is about typical.
Year by year
The arrival date in each year, 2015–2025.
Show the table
| Year | Fall sightings | Arrival | Compared with typical | Half arrived | Activity-adjusted | Spring departure |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | 878 | Oct 11 | On the typical date | Nov 3 | Oct 16 | May 10 |
| 2016 | 368 | Oct 1 | 10 days early, unusually | Nov 5 | Oct 23 | May 12 |
| 2017 | 470 | Oct 18 | 6 days late | Nov 9 | Oct 15 | May 12 |
| 2018 | 2,782 | Oct 21 | 10 days late, unusually | Nov 14 | Oct 25 | May 14 |
| 2019 | 82 | Oct 11 | On the typical date | Nov 8 | Oct 17 | May 16 |
| 2020 | 9,495 | Oct 10 | 2 days early, near normal | Oct 31 | Oct 7 | May 18 |
| 2021 | 332 | Oct 8 | 3 days early | Nov 10 | Oct 17 | May 13 |
| 2022 | 884 | Oct 15 | 4 days late | Nov 9 | Oct 25 | May 10 |
| 2023 | 2,613 | Oct 14 | 2 days late, near normal | Nov 6 | Oct 12 | May 18 |
| 2024 | 961 | Oct 18 | 6 days late | Nov 9 | Oct 24 | May 11 |
| 2025 | 903 | Oct 9 | 3 days early | Nov 4 | Oct 13 | May 12 |
When they leave in spring
Most have gone by May 12 in a typical year: 90% of spring sightings are in by then, and only stragglers are seen after. It ranged from May 10 to May 18 in most years, and 2020 ran latest (May 18). Allowing for birdwatcher activity, sightings drop below half their spring peak after about May 6. Our 2015-2024 date (May 13) matched the 2025 departure to the day.
By county
20 New York counties have enough sightings for their own date. Earliest: Monroe County (Oct 6), Oswego County (Oct 7), Onondaga County (Oct 8). Latest: Saratoga County (Oct 16), Nassau County (Oct 15), Westchester County (Oct 14).
Show all 20 counties
| County | Arrival | Compared with state | Sightings | 2025 check |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monroe County | Oct 6 | 5 days earlier | 1,607 | ±4 days |
| Oswego County | Oct 7 | 4 days earlier | 374 | n/a |
| Onondaga County | Oct 8 | 3 days earlier | 443 | n/a |
| Suffolk County | Oct 10 | 1 day earlier | 1,574 | n/a |
| Tompkins County | Oct 10 | 1 day earlier | 1,397 | ±6 days |
| Dutchess County | Oct 10 | 1 day earlier | 427 | n/a |
| Sullivan County | Oct 10 | 1 day earlier | 397 | n/a |
| Essex County | Oct 11 | Same | 522 | n/a |
| Erie County | Oct 12 | 1 day later | 379 | ±5 days |
| Orange County | Oct 12 | 1 day later | 433 | n/a |
| Richmond County | Oct 12 | 1 day later | 524 | n/a |
| New York County | Oct 13 | 2 days later | 831 | n/a |
| Wayne County | Oct 13 | 2 days later | 337 | n/a |
| Ulster County | Oct 13 | 2 days later | 426 | n/a |
| Queens County | Oct 14 | 3 days later | 575 | n/a |
| Franklin County | Oct 14 | 3 days later | 365 | n/a |
| Kings County | Oct 14 | 3 days later | 1,332 | n/a |
| Westchester County | Oct 14 | 3 days later | 723 | n/a |
| Nassau County | Oct 15 | 4 days later | 853 | n/a |
| Saratoga County | Oct 16 | 5 days later | 327 | n/a |
Nearby states
| State | Typical arrival | Difference | Spring departure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Connecticut | Oct 19 | 8 days later | May 6 |
| Massachusetts | Oct 11 | Same day | May 11 |
| New Jersey | Oct 18 | 7 days later | May 8 |
| Pennsylvania | Oct 18 | 7 days later | May 8 |
| Vermont | Oct 12 | 1 day later | May 13 |
Farther away, the closest timing: North Carolina (Oct 11, same day), Illinois (Oct 11, same day), New Hampshire (Oct 10, 1 day earlier), Indiana (Oct 13, 2 days later).
More birds in New York
- American Robins all year
- Blue Jays all year
- Northern Cardinals all year
- Mourning Doves all year
- Black-capped Chickadees all year
- American Crows all year
- Song Sparrows all year
- Canada Geese all year
- American Goldfinches all year
- European Starlings all year
- Red-winged Blackbirds Mar 13
- Downy Woodpeckers all year
- House Sparrows all year
- Red-bellied Woodpeckers all year
- Mallards all year
- Common Grackles Mar 16
- Tufted Titmice all year
- White-breasted Nuthatches all year
- Gray Catbirds May 3
- White-throated Sparrows Oct 2
- Ring-billed Gulls all year
- Dark-eyed Juncos passage visitor
- Northern Flickers all year
- House Finches all year
- All 318 birds in New York
Get ready
Product searches on Amazon. We are not paid for these links.
Email me before they arrive
Enter your ZIP code and we'll email you about 10 days before Pine Siskins usually reach your county in New York. Never more than one email a day.
Share it on your site
Bird clubs, nature centers and garden shops can add a free badge with the New York arrival window. It links back here and carries the data credit.
Get the badge