When the Birds Come Back
Corrections and takedown policy
We want every figure on When the Birds Come Back to be right. If something is wrong, out of date, or should not be here, tell us.
How to report. Use the form below or the "Report an error" link on any page (it records the page), or email corrections@birdarrivals.com. Tell us the page, what is wrong, and, if you can, a link to the correct source.
Thanks. We have your report.
Too many reports from here today. Please try again later, or email corrections@birdarrivals.com.
That report did not go through: please describe what is wrong, or email corrections@birdarrivals.com.
Our response times
| Type | We acknowledge within | We aim to resolve within |
|---|---|---|
| Data error (any figure) | 5 business days | 10 business days |
| Copyright notice (DMCA) | 2 business days | Promptly once a complete notice is received |
| A data publisher withdraws permission or asks us to stop | 2 business days | Data pages offline within 48 hours of confirmation |
| Accessibility barrier | 5 business days | 30 days |
What we publish. Accepted corrections are listed below with the date, the page, the old and new values and the cause. We do not publish the names of people who report.
What we will not change. We do not change a computed figure that correctly follows our published method. We will explain the method and link the source.
If a data publisher asks us to stop. The data pages can be taken offline with a single rebuild; only the explainer pages stay up, and the change is logged here.
Copyright (DMCA). Send notices to our designated agent: Copyright Agent, Orith Apps LLC, copyright@birdarrivals.com. Under 17 U.S.C. § 512(c)(3) the notice must include your signature, identification of the work and of the material with its URL, your contact details, a good-faith statement, and a statement under penalty of perjury that the notice is accurate and that you are authorised to act for the owner.
Corrections log
Changes to published figures since the site launched on 2026-11-15, newest first. Changes to how we work out a figure are also described on methods.
| Date | Pages | Was | Now | Cause |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-11-16 | Top of bird-and-state pages and the state calendar tables | “2025 arrival 3 days late” beside a typical date that includes 2025; early years rounded down by a day (14.5 shown as 14 next to ±15) | Labelled “2025 vs 2015–2024”, and halves rounded the same way in both directions | The figure was measured against a different baseline than the date printed beside it. |
| 2026-11-16 | Resident and visitor bird pages (e.g. Canada Geese in North Carolina, Black-capped Chickadees in Washington) | “They become common again around August 1” (or January 1), with “matched 2025 to the day” | No “common again” date where the bird is already common when the season starts | The rise detector returned the first day of its search window. |
| 2026-11-16 | County pages and the “By county” tables on bird pages; county dates in arrival alerts | County dates from weekly counts compared directly with the statewide date, which made almost every county “earlier than the state” for early-spring birds (all 49 Ohio counties for Common Grackles) | County dates set on the statewide scale, so “earlier” and “later” compare like with like | County and state dates came from two methods that differ by up to 19 days in late winter. |
| 2026-11-16 | Bird pages for summer birds that winter in small numbers (e.g. Yellow Warblers in Florida, Cedar Waxwings in Maine) | A spring arrival date from a season window starting on January 1 | No arrival date; the page describes the bird as present all year or as a winter visitor | The January 1 window counted wintering birds as spring arrivals. |
| 2026-11-16 | Bird-and-state pages for irruptive and erratic birds (birds that come in large numbers in some years and hardly at all in others) | A single “most years they are back by” date | “Come in some years only” or a range of years, with no single date | Years when the birds did not come were treated as late arrivals. |
| 2026-11-16 | Feeder dates on species, feeder, county and alert pages | Put-out and take-down dates worked out by slightly different rules on each page type | One rule for every page: a week before the earliest regular summer bird is back in an early year, and two weeks after a late-year departure | The same state showed different feeder dates on different pages. |
| 2026-11-16 | Hummingbird feeder pages for California, Arizona, Oregon, Washington, Texas, Louisiana and Florida (/hummingbird-feeders/<state>/) | A take-down date, e.g. “Take them down after October 6” (California) | “Keep one feeder up all year”, because some hummingbirds stay the winter in these states | The take-down rule ignored hummingbirds that stay all winter. |