Feeder guide
Tube and hopper seed feeders

Source: eBird Observation Dataset (Cornell Lab of Ornithology) via GBIF, records 2015–2025, CC BY 4.0; summarized into typical dates, not a forecast. Data updated Nov 16, 2026; refreshed once a year when GBIF publishes a new eBird release. Feeding advice is quoted from the agencies and extension services linked in the text. Methodology · Report an error
A tube or hopper of black-oil sunflower seed is the simplest feeder that brings in the most birds. “Black oil sunflower seed appeals to the greatest number of birds. Offer sunflower seeds, nyjer (thistle) seeds, and peanuts in separate feeders.” (National Audubon Society) Penn State Extension agrees: “If you are going to provide one seed, this is the one to choose.” (Penn State Extension)
Nyjer for finches
“Niger or thistle seed is popular because of its attractiveness to goldfinches, house finches, and purple finches.” (Penn State Extension) Nyjer is tiny, so it needs its own tube with small ports. Purple Finches come and go with the seasons in some states. They usually turn up in Illinois around Oct 6, Indiana around Oct 8, Kansas around Nov 6 and Arkansas around Nov 8.
Keep the seed dry and the tube clean
- “Damp seeds may grow mold that can be fatal to birds.” (National Audubon Society)
- “At a minimum, all feeders should be taken down, emptied of all contents, and cleaned at least once every two weeks.” (Virginia Cooperative Extension)
- For the cleaning mix: “The National Wildlife Health Center recommends cleaning bird baths and feeders with a solution of nine parts water to one part bleach.” (National Audubon Society)
Watch the ground too
Some of the busiest winter visitors never land on the tube. “Sparrows, juncos, and towhees usually feed on the ground” (National Audubon Society), so they pick up what spills. Dark-eyed Juncos usually arrive from Oct 1 in the earliest state to Nov 12 in the latest. See the platform and ground feeding guide for dates by state.
What to look for
Paid links: each row opens an Amazon search for that kind of feeder. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. These picks are based on specs, not hands-on testing; we show no prices or ratings, so check them on Amazon before you buy.
- Tube feeder for sunflower. Metal ports and a metal cap, a removable base for cleaning, and a size you will empty in a few days so the seed stays dry. See options on Amazon
- Hopper feeder. A roof that overhangs the seed tray, drainage in the tray, and a lid that opens wide enough to scrub inside. See options on Amazon
- Nyjer tube. Small ports sized for nyjer, which pours straight out of a sunflower tube. See options on Amazon
Keep every feeder clean
“At a minimum, all feeders should be taken down, emptied of all contents, and cleaned at least once every two weeks.” (Virginia Cooperative Extension) Diseases that spread at feeders include “house finch eye disease (the colloquial name for mycoplasmal conjunctivitis” (National Audubon Society) and salmonellosis. On bird flu, the US Fish and Wildlife Service says “Bird feeders are unlikely to result in increased spread of avian influenza since the species of bird that tend to come to feeders are not commonly infected.” (US Fish and Wildlife Service) Follow your state wildlife agency if it says otherwise.